Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Direct contact between supplier and user, bypassing procurement staff in an organization is not a positive approach. Do you favour such a policy?

user-image
Question added by Nadeem Asghar , Supply Chain Consultant/Trainer , Independent Practitioner
Date Posted: 2016/10/25

Direct contact between supplier and end user and not procurement department is not positive approach - in my opinion, any contact between supplier and end user department should be routed through procurement department. Such interactions may be necessary for better understanding of client specifications, clarifications before placing order, so that it is followed immediately with a clear design document submitted by supplier at the quoted price

Manzoor Alam
by Manzoor Alam , Director , 7th Sky Travel & Tourism Services (Pvt.) Limited

It all depending upon the need, in some cases could be allowed with soft checks /controls but every action should be under the agreed and established SOPs.

osama khalifa
by osama khalifa , sourcing manager , Toshiba

of course , purchasing is very important process to add your profit 

Amna Sultana
by Amna Sultana , Spare Parts & Logistics Officer , Akbar Ali & Sons

Well, It depends because its necessary for the organization if they want to procure something I guess its not a  negative sign. Similarly, depending on the scale of your project, there could be a very wide range of potential solutions and approaches to the business need and a number of ways of researching the market and selecting a supplier Such kind of policies make their work in right direction.

Harbi Khabour
by Harbi Khabour , Supply Chain Officer , MSF - Médecins Sans Frontières

Every organization has a procedures for supplying and it start by the user requests to the Supply department which start the procurement and purchasing procedures to provide the requested materials to the user and this is a flood materials monitoring and cost reduction plans. So no.

Md Fazlur Rahman
by Md Fazlur Rahman , Procurement Specialist , Engineering and Planning Consultants Ltd

Direct contact between supplier and user by passing procurement staff is not desirable.

It creates unnecessary bias towards particulars supplier(s), suppliers may push their own product specification to the user and it may reduce effective competition.  

If the user wants to know what is available in the market, user  may ask the procurement department for required literature or brochure and then draft spec. and send to procurement department for action.

 

Khalid Abuzaid
by Khalid Abuzaid , Supply Chain Director , National Integrated Industries Complex – Jordan

I don't prefer such contact between the suppliers and the users unless there is a technical issue to be discussed with the user 

Imran Khan
by Imran Khan , Logistics Manager , Transmed Overseas Incorporated

By passing procuremnt is not a possitive approach but there are some regular orders for which the user department cant wait for purchase approval and teh value of stock is small, therefore some organization allow direct contact in some specific catagories of items, with small monetary value.

Terrence Walmsley
by Terrence Walmsley , Owner , The Awesome Group of Companies

In some special cases, the answer would be "yes". These would refer to the gathering of technical specifications or mechanical properties. However, when it comes down to the procurement process, this should be left to the procurement staff.

Hussein Alsawy
by Hussein Alsawy , مدير سلسلة التوريد , سري

According to type of business, there are many policies in procurement, one of them is Vendor's management or Vendor's relation, I agree with that policy if you are selling a services like credit cards or shipping activities ... etc, but in items I don't like at all because it will makes some thing of self competency and may the user understand something by mistake as he is not familiar with other business tasks. 

Ali Akbar Mazumder
by Ali Akbar Mazumder , Deputy Manager (Planning) , Meghna Group of Industries

Such policy basically differs from organization to organization. I think it is very important to have direct contact with the supplier and user. The benefit of such contacts are-

1. The supplier can understand the core requirement of the user

2. The user can get exactly what he wants

3. Supplier-customer relationship improves

4. Both parties can share same requirements with procurement staff which helps them in placing orders as per end user requirements to the supplier.

The negotiation part should solely depends on the procurement staff but the requirements can be shared with suppliers directly by end user.

For easy understanding i would like to share the real time example in this case. In GlaxoSmithKline (gsk) Bangladesh Limited, the material schedulers, production officers, and other dept.'s end user directly communicate with suppliers about their requirements. Upon their basic understanding the respective dept's personnel share the purchase requisition with the procurement dept. Based on the purchase requisition, the procurement dept. invites for quotation. With comparative statement, he identifies the lowest quoted suppliers against the requirement. Then he (procurement staff) solely negotiate with suppliers about products prices and maintaining quality.

More Questions Like This

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.