Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What are the causes of failure of earthen dams?

user-image
Question added by محمد يونس , مهندس مشرف , الشركة العامة للكهرباء
Date Posted: 2015/01/12
جعفر هندي زين السقاف
by جعفر هندي زين السقاف , مهندس أستشاري , مشاريع اﻻشغال العامة

The causes of failure of earthen dams are: 

Dam failures are of particular concern because the failure of a large dam has the potential to cause more death and destruction than the failure of any other man-made structure. This is because of the destructive power of the flood wave that would be released by the sudden collapse of a large dam.Tailing dams, which sometimes store toxic materials, may pose additional dangers eg Omai Tailings Dam, Guyana failed in1995 releasing cyanide slurries and Stava Tailings Dam, Italy failed in1985 killing268 people. Many dams, both large and small, have failed but only a few have had a significant impact on the practice of dam design and engineering geology. The most common causes of dam failures are:

 

Overtopping of embankment dams due to inadequate spillway discharge capacity to pass flood waters. This is one of the most common causes of dam failures and has nothing to do with the geology of the dam site. Any embankment dam will fail if the spillway is too small and flood waters rise high enough to flow over the top of the dam wall. The estimation of the size of the maximum flood a dam will have to survive during its life is a science which has undergone continuing evolution over the last century with the result that many dams built decades ago may now be judged to have inadequate spillways even though the spillways were designed to standards of safety which were accepted as adequate at the time of construction of the dam. Many millions of dollars has been spent upgrading the flood handling capacities of many existing dams, both embankment and concrete dams, as a result.

 

The Burrinjuck Dam Flood Security Upgrading project is a recent example.

 

Faults in construction methods (eg inadequate compaction of fill) or use of the wrong type of construction materials (eg silt) may lead to internal erosion or piping failures of embankment dams. An example is the failure of the Teton Dam in Idaho, USA in1976. 

 

Geological problems with the dam foundation. The failure of the St. Francis Dam falls into this category. After the failure it was found that some of the foundation rock, a conglomerate, disintegrated when the rock was immersed in water so that the rock lost all its strength when saturated. This is exactly what happened as the newly completed dam filled with water for the first time and the dam failed shortly afterwards. Another example of a dam break due to foundation failure is the Malpasset Dam in France which failed in1959. This was the first collapse of a modern, thin concrete arch dam.

 

Landslides which fall into the storage reservoir, sending a wave of water over the top of the dam may cause a dam to fail, or the dam may survive if made of concrete but a destructive flood may still devastate the river valley downstream as happened at the Vaiont Dam in Italy in1963 when over1900 people were killed. 

 

Earthquakes can certainly cause damage to dams but complete failure of a large dam due to earthquake damage appears to be very rare. The Lower San Fernando Dam in California, USA did fail during an earthquake in1971 which caused the fill in the dam wall to liquefy resulting in the collapse of the upstream part of the dam. A disastrous flood was only prevented because the reservoir level happened to be low at the time of the earthquake and no water escaped downstream.

 

Dams are likely to exist, perhaps for hundreds of years, even after they are no longer required for their original purpose. During these years, dangerous alterations to the operation of the dam and/or its structure may lead to failure eg South Fork Dam (Johnstown) which failed in1889. Incorrect operation of a dam at any time can result in overtopping and failure eg Euclides da Cunha Dam, Brazil which failed in1977.

Alex Al Yazouri
by Alex Al Yazouri , General Manager , Al Mushref Cooperative Society

  • Sub-standard construction materials/techniques
  • Spillway design error
  • Geological instability caused by changes to water levels during filling or poor surveying
  • Sliding of a mountain into the reservoir
  • Poor maintenance, especially of outlet pipes
  • Extreme inflow
  • Human, computer or design error
  • Internal erosion, especially in earthen dams
  • Earthquakes

Muhammad Shakeel
by Muhammad Shakeel , CAD Design Manager , M/S zeeruk Intl.

Most of the earth dams fails due to design fault, improper Construction, and also some of the time poor maintenance practice of the dam structure. The various causes of failure may be classified as over topping Failure, Hydraulic failure, Seepage failure, Structural failure, earth quick, sliding of Mountain, surface or toe erosion etc.

Agreed with my seniors. 

 

Mohamed Galal Hussein Ahmed Mohamed
by Mohamed Galal Hussein Ahmed Mohamed , Technical Mnager , Fast Building Contracting Co.

We can divide those reasons to three main reasons:

a) Hydraulic failure:

Hydraulic accounts for over40% of earth dam failure and may be due to one or more of the following: i) By overtopping:

ii). Erosion of downstream toe

iii) Erosion of upstream surface

iv). Erosion of downstream face by gully formation

b). Seepage failure:

Seepage always occurs in the dams. If the magnitude is within design limits, it may not harm the stability of the dam. However, if seepage is concentrated or uncontrolled beyond limits, it will lead to failure of the dam. Following are some of the various types of seepage failure.

i) Piping through dam body.

ii) Piping through foundation

iii) Sloughing of downstream side of dam:

The process of failure due to sloughing starts when the downstream toe of the dam becomes saturated and starts getting eroded, causing small slump or slide of the dam. The small slide leaves a relative steep face, which also becomes saturated due to seepage and also slumps again and forms more unstable surface. The process of saturation and slumping continues, leading to failure of dam.

c) Structural Failure:

About25% of failure is attributed to structural failure, which is mainly due to shear failure causing slide along the slopes. The failure may be due to:

Slide in embankment:

ii) Foundation slide:

iii) Faulty construction and poor maintenance: When during construction, the compaction of the embankment is not properly done, it may lead to failure.

iv)  Earthquake may cause the following types of failure to earthfill dams;

1- crack may develop in the core wall, causing leakages and piping failure.

2. Slow waves may set up due to shaking of reservoir bottom, and dam may fail due to overtopping

3. Settlement of dam which may reduce freeboard causing failure by overtopping

4. Sliding of natural hills causing damage to dam and its appurtenant structures

5. Fault movement in the dam site reducing reservoir capacity and causing overtopping.

6. Shear slide of dam

7. The sand below foundation may liquefy

8. Failure of slope pitching.

 

 

 

 

ماحي عابد
by ماحي عابد , Civil engineer , Technical building control

Convincing answers

Ameen Alolofi
by Ameen Alolofi , مهندس مدني , وزارة الاشغال العامة والطرق

the causes of failure of earthen dams may be one of these 

soil under the dam is weak by water .

RC foundations don't have piles .

thickness of dam not as required

pressure of water is over critical

dam's earth is very small or limestone is one of his continent 

soil quantity is very much 

but the water is the main cause .

Mubashar Ali
by Mubashar Ali , Assistant Manager Operation at Orange line Metro Rail , Gaungzhou -Norinco-Daewoo JV

1) WEAK SOIL COMPACTION 

2) use of Non cohesive soil in the construction of dam. 

 

Muhammad Khalil
by Muhammad Khalil , Chief Engineer (Civil) , Water and Sanitation Services Mardan

Agree with brother yaqoob and Alex. Good answers

 

Zahid Umar
by Zahid Umar , Civil Works & Power Implementation Engineer , Telenor

Seepage, settlement. overturning,

More Questions Like This

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.